Historical Accuracy and Chaos Warrior Armour

[bruenor]

Dude, they're 25 year old miniatures

LOL this.

I do dislike the comparissons between real life things and miniatures.
They aren't real, they are fantasy miniatures and therefore real life rules don't apply, just enjoy them.

Bloody good painting too RW, I'd leave them as is.

[chaoticprime]

There was no argument for anyone to agree or disagree with either me or Sjeng. I stated an observation, not a criticism.

I did not make the argument that they should be historically accurate. But since you all took it that way, allow me my response.

Point: "They should be historically accurate."
Counter-point: "They're just miniatures."
Defense: Logical fallacy.
or
Point: "They should be historically accurate."
Counter-point: "They're 25 years old."
Defense: Logical fallacy.
or
Point: "They should be historically accurate."
Counter-point: "They're fantasy miniatures."
Defense: Logical fallacy.

The correct argument would have been:

Point: "They should be historically accurate."
Counter-point: "Why?"