Make a small donation to Ye Olde Inn!
Every cent received goes toward Ye Olde Inn's maintenance and allows us to continue providing the best resources for HeroQuest and Fantasy Gaming fans.


Make a small donation to Ye Olde Inn!
Every cent received goes toward Ye Olde Inn's maintenance and allows us to continue providing the best resources for HeroQuest and Fantasy Gaming fans.
Onan wrote:So you would replace the door by an open door and only reveal the monster right behind the door, not the rest of the room? Hmm, this feels a bit artificial.


The Admiral wrote:For me, the doorway monster breaks the must enter rule and means fudges are now required to cope with the anomaly.




1st Edition wrote:The player characters place their models on any square next to the stairway.


Onan wrote:It's the same anomaly as with Pass through Rock: https://www.forum.yeoldeinn.com/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=1281&start=160
In order to reveal an area you need to step in, but as it is revealed it turns out that you are not allowed to step in. Even after over 10 years of debate the HeroQuest sages haven't found a definitive answer.


Onan wrote:I guess we all misplay the following rule:1st Edition wrote:The player characters place their models on any square next to the stairway.
Everybody puts the heroes on the stairway, not next to it.
In Bastion of Chaos it is not even possible to put the heroes next to the stairway


Onan wrote:So you would replace the door by an open door and only reveal the monster right behind the door, not the rest of the room? Hmm, this feels a bit artificial.
BlackJax Guide to Line-of-Sight rules in HeroQuest wrote:A figure can be seen by another figure only if you can trace an unobstructed straight line between the centre of the squares occupied by the two figures. If the line passes through a wall, or closed door, then the figure is not visible.
= "special skull" that counts as a "skull" but can be rolled again, once, counting as a normal "skull" if rolled again.
= "skull"
= "shield" cancels out a skull (hero & monster)
on your movement roll then the evil wizard player may immediately place a Wandering Monster

Daedalus wrote:I believe my old group has handled NA treasure searches wrong. We used to allow the other three Heroes to take Treasure Cards after the first Hero had discovered special treasure from the Quest Notes. "A room may be searched by all four Heroes..." and "The special treasure is discovered only once by the first Hero who searches the room for treasure, even if other Heroes later search that same room"; both of those statements led us to believe the point of later treasure searches by other Heroes was to take Treasure Cards. We didn't consider that the text of the last sentence was instead only to exclude the possibility of a special treasure from being repeatedly awarded.
After thinking through the logic of why only single searches are allowed in the EU rules (see another thread), I've at last come to identify the same limitation in the NA rules where a room contains special treasure: only one treasure search is allowed. "If there is no special treasure called out to Zargon in the Quest Book, you, as a Hero, must draw a random card from the Treasure Card deck . . .." Conversely, if there is special treasure called out, Heroes may NOT draw a Treasure Card. After the first search finds the special treasure, no other searches are possible.
I'd even go so far as to say an empty chest or weapons rack with useless weapons could count as special treasure from the notes--it has a description, even if not positive. That means no treasure for the room!

dragon5145 wrote:Daedalus wrote:I believe my old group has handled NA treasure searches wrong. We used to allow the other three Heroes to take Treasure Cards after the first Hero had discovered special treasure from the Quest Notes. "A room may be searched by all four Heroes..." and "The special treasure is discovered only once by the first Hero who searches the room for treasure, even if other Heroes later search that same room"; both of those statements led us to believe the point of later treasure searches by other Heroes was to take Treasure Cards. We didn't consider that the text of the last sentence was instead only to exclude the possibility of a special treasure from being repeatedly awarded.
After thinking through the logic of why only single searches are allowed in the EU rules (see another thread), I've at last come to identify the same limitation in the NA rules where a room contains special treasure: only one treasure search is allowed. "If there is no special treasure called out to Zargon in the Quest Book, you, as a Hero, must draw a random card from the Treasure Card deck . . .." Conversely, if there is special treasure called out, Heroes may NOT draw a Treasure Card. After the first search finds the special treasure, no other searches are possible.
I'd even go so far as to say an empty chest or weapons rack with useless weapons could count as special treasure from the notes--it has a description, even if not positive. That means no treasure for the room!
Yeah none of the editions so far have had rules that adequately define treasure search limits that don't require some form of house rules. NA rules came closest with it one per hero per room, but your logic for rooms does have merit and I would agree with your rule especially for those that just say that chest or weapon rack is empty. However most Quest notes in NA read the first hero to search for treasure finds x, this seems to indicate the possibility of a second, third, and fourth hero being able to search, just they would draw a card. Once again all up to an individual or group's interpretation.
Then are they really playing incorrectly?


Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest