• Advertisement

Make a small donation to Ye Olde Inn!

Donate via Paypal

Every cent received goes toward Ye Olde Inn's maintenance and allows us to continue providing the best resources for HeroQuest and Fantasy Gaming fans.

Heroquest Revisited

Topics related to Games Workshops Advanced HeroQuest.

Re: Heroquest Revisited

Postby RECIVS » Yesterday, 10:00 am

Foilfodder wrote:
RECIVS wrote:...players making decisions for the DM in an RPG-like game isn't ideal by any measure, and you can Google it, ask the AI, or whatever. It's clearly a flaw, poor game design by any objective standard. Are we going to keep such a flaw out of nostalgia alone to preserve AHQ as close to the vanilla version as possible? How would that help the game in the end? Now extrapolate that same—nostalgia blind—approach to all the game's other problems, and we end up with what we have today: a flaw-romanticizing paradigm to “fix” AHQ.


If you don't like the game rules, RECIVS, you are entitled to that opinion. However, when comparing Advanced Heroquest with other games, or just rating it on its own, please remember Advanced Heroquest wasn't designed as a Solo Play game. It is a game designed to be lead by a Gamemaster. The Solo Play rules are optional and take up just a page and a half toward the back of the rulebook. Stating that the game designers left in a flaw due to poor game design is too harsh.

Fitting examples when a thing is used for a task it can do, but wasn't meant for:
- Fishing with dynamite.
- Hammering a nail with a screwdriver.
You probably get the idea....

My friend, I’m afraid you keep proving my point with each post.

I get the idea of a flaw-romanticizing paradigm perfectly well; the one that considers it “too harsh” to suggest that AHQ is poorly designed, flawed, or that it shouldn’t be that bland and repetitive.

As I’ve said in other posts and threads, it’s pretty clear what kind of game AHQ was supposed to be. It’s also obvious what a boardgame dungeon crawler is and what game design principles it involves. I've written about it extensively—just see my first few posts in this thread, for example. In the end, the facts remain the same.

AHQ not designed as a solo-play game? What the heck are you even talking about? It's kept me hooked for 14 years without ever playing with anyone! I’ve said repeatedly that I haven’t found another DC that delivers the same level of dread and unpredictability when playing solo. I also said that they don’t make them like that anymore, with few components and short setup times. AHQ just needs some work to take more advantage of its potential, but I know suggesting the obvious may sound like sacrilege to some people, which only proves my point, again.

I do love AHQ and understand the context; the difference is that I’m immune to the nostalgia factor, and I certainly don’t romanticize its flaws. I know it was the first solo-friendly board game dungeon crawler ever, that its designer was inexperienced, and that the deadline was tight; it all makes perfect sense to me.

So, back to the actual topic: regardless of our preferences, we can agree that making decisions for the DM in an RPG-like game isn't ideal by any objective standard, and that it’s clearly a flaw, right? Just look at what other solo games of the type do, for Christ's sake!

The irony is that sometimes the same people who tell you to play a game the way you enjoy it are the same people who end up telling you (wrongly, by the way) how not to play it.
User avatar
RECIVS

Ogre Lord
Ogre Lord
 
Posts: 269
Images: 0
Joined: July 18th, 2017, 1:36 am
Location: MTY NL MX
Forum Language: English (United States)
Usergroups:
Champion Group Member

Advertisement

Make a small donation to Ye Olde Inn!

Donate via Paypal

Every cent received goes toward Ye Olde Inn's maintenance and allows us to continue providing the best resources for HeroQuest and Fantasy Gaming fans.

Re: Heroquest Revisited

Postby Foilfodder » Yesterday, 10:39 am

Foilfodder wrote:If you don't like the game rules, RECIVS, you are entitled to that opinion. However, when comparing Advanced Heroquest with other games, or just rating it on its own, please remember Advanced Heroquest wasn't designed as a Solo Play game. It is a game designed to be lead by a Gamemaster. The Solo Play rules are optional and take up just a page and a half toward the back of the rulebook. Stating that the game designers left in a flaw due to poor game design is too harsh.


RECIVS wrote:My friend, I’m afraid you keep proving my point with each post.


I'm afraid you have me confused with someone else in this thread. Up until my last post, my other replies were to Onan and Thanquol, not you. Two answering Onan's question on how I would move the Skaven which mentioned the leader as a halberd and another also to Onan mentioning bow fire in death zones is not allowed. One to Thanquol regarding the historic information he provided on the HeroQuest vs Heroquest copyright.

I now withdraw from this topic.
User avatar
Foilfodder

Zombie
Zombie
 
Posts: 34
Images: 5
Joined: July 5th, 2025, 10:01 am
Forum Language: English (United States)
Hero:
Evil Sorcerer: Zargon
Usergroups:
Champion Group Member

Re: Heroquest Revisited

Postby RECIVS » Yesterday, 11:22 am

Foilfodder wrote:
Foilfodder wrote:If you don't like the game rules, RECIVS, you are entitled to that opinion. However, when comparing Advanced Heroquest with other games, or just rating it on its own, please remember Advanced Heroquest wasn't designed as a Solo Play game. It is a game designed to be lead by a Gamemaster. The Solo Play rules are optional and take up just a page and a half toward the back of the rulebook. Stating that the game designers left in a flaw due to poor game design is too harsh.


RECIVS wrote:My friend, I’m afraid you keep proving my point with each post.


I'm afraid you have me confused with someone else in this thread. Up until my last post, my other replies were to Onan and Thanquol, not you. Two answering Onan's question on how I would move the Skaven which mentioned the leader as a halberd and another also to Onan mentioning bow fire in death zones is not allowed. One to Thanquol regarding the historic information he provided on the HeroQuest vs Heroquest copyright.

I now withdraw from this topic.

Sure! No problem. Happy gaming! |_P
User avatar
RECIVS

Ogre Lord
Ogre Lord
 
Posts: 269
Images: 0
Joined: July 18th, 2017, 1:36 am
Location: MTY NL MX
Forum Language: English (United States)
Usergroups:
Champion Group Member

Re: Heroquest Revisited

Postby RECIVS » Yesterday, 5:33 pm

RECIVS wrote: |_P

Fishing with dynamite, speaking of being too harsh—*irony detector goes off the charts!* :mrgreen:
User avatar
RECIVS

Ogre Lord
Ogre Lord
 
Posts: 269
Images: 0
Joined: July 18th, 2017, 1:36 am
Location: MTY NL MX
Forum Language: English (United States)
Usergroups:
Champion Group Member

Re: Heroquest Revisited

Postby Onan » Today, 4:42 am

Yesterday I started Tobaro's Bane level2. Level1 took me 3 hours to finish, although it only had 2 rooms, and the prospect of scrolling trough the rulebook again gave me headaches in advance. So I made screenshots of the hero, henchmen and skaven stats, the Shattered Amulet tables and the GM reference sheet. Now I can switch between those with a singe swipe. This is a huge difference in game flow. Suddenly I'm able to play through encounters smoothly and the game begins to shine.

I found 3 interesting hazards: A statue that turned into a skaven warlord (he was alone and had no chance), a room full of rats (I slammed the door because I lacked the greek fire), and a trap door in the floor (but I didn't have a rope).

Here we surround the statue before removing the gem:
ahqstatue.JPG


2 lairs and some wandering monsters cost me 2 of the henchmen and the seargent's fate point, and the other 2 henchman were at only 1 wound left. The quest room, that came so early in level1, was nowhere to be found. The level turned into a maze of corridors, like a snake that bites its own tail:
ahqcorridorcircle.JPG


I went to bed, knowing that I had made no progress at all, because the chances of finding the quest room are always the same, no matter how far I have already explored. But alas, this morning I found a secret door right next to the starting stairs and rolled a 12: the quest room.
ahqlevel2questroom.JPG


6 warrios, 2 champions plus the 2 characters from Tobaro's Bane: a warp weaver and a plague monk. The heroes won the surprise, and I decided not to place the first skaven right behind the door (the only square from which he can attack), but scatter them in the room HeroQuest style, keeping the characters apart from each other.

The party rushed in, and the wizard spent his last spell components to burn the warp weaver and a warrior in the flames of death. The other heroes also killed some skaven, but couldn't get through to the plague monk. In the GM phase the skaven closed in on the heroes, protecting the monk, who started his warp scroll.

ahqlevel2questroom2.JPG


In the second round the heroes cut a whole into the skaven wall, and the dwarf reached the monk, but failed his attack. The monk is now in the dwarf's death zone, but the warp scroll was already started before, so it looks like this does not prevent its completion. The intelligence test passed, and all heroes and henchmen aged fast an died of old age. The heroes each spent a fate point to rejuvenate, but the seargent and henchmen could not be saved.

ahqlevel2end.JPG

And that's the end of level2. All heroes have 3 wounds and 1 fate point left. The wizard is "empty". The quest demands to kill Cankerclaw in a single expedition, so level 3 will be a standard dungeon played with weakened heroes. This will be tough!

I have to say that I like AHQ by now. :) :redheart: The combat system is smooth, dungeon generation is feasible when you have all necessary table ready at hand. The game tells some very good stories.

RECIVS you're right that placing the monsters right behind the door doesn't make sense. But I think this rule can easily be replaced by the default placing rules or a general guideline: "Scatter the monsters inside the room. If the heroes win the surprise, place them slightly to the herores' advantage, but always protect the characters from a direct rush."
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
User avatar
Onan

Gargoyle
Gargoyle
 
Posts: 128
Joined: March 7th, 2025, 4:01 pm
Hero:
Evil Sorcerer: Morcar
Usergroups:
Champion Group Member

Re: Heroquest Revisited

Postby RECIVS » Today, 11:51 am

Onan wrote:RECIVS you're right that placing the monsters right behind the door doesn't make sense. But I think this rule can easily be replaced by the default placing rules or a general guideline: "Scatter the monsters inside the room. If the heroes win the surprise, place them slightly to the herores' advantage, but always protect the characters from a direct rush."

The problem is repetition, and you shouldn't be making decisions for the GM, which gets boring in the long run (once you realize what you're actually doing as a player). Using ranged enemies every time isn't a solution either; you'd just be implementing a different form of repetition. Did you see this and this? I'm also putting together my Re-Reforged rules for controlling monsters as a separate document.

Sometimes people say they don’t care about repetition in a DC or deciding for the GM in solo mode; maybe they don’t really like the actual game as much as they're attached to the memories of playing it decades ago.

On the other hand, you should be using the exploration rules from Terror in the Dark; I thought I had advised you sooner about that.
User avatar
RECIVS

Ogre Lord
Ogre Lord
 
Posts: 269
Images: 0
Joined: July 18th, 2017, 1:36 am
Location: MTY NL MX
Forum Language: English (United States)
Usergroups:
Champion Group Member

Re: Heroquest Revisited

Postby RECIVS » Today, 12:22 pm

RECIVS wrote:this

For the record, even the most adamant paladins of thematic coherence go mute when you ask them to show you a depiction of doorway fighting in the game’s original artwork. Isn't the artwork a crucial aspect of the game's theme? Aren’t we supposed to do justice to that to begin with?
User avatar
RECIVS

Ogre Lord
Ogre Lord
 
Posts: 269
Images: 0
Joined: July 18th, 2017, 1:36 am
Location: MTY NL MX
Forum Language: English (United States)
Usergroups:
Champion Group Member

Previous

Return to Advanced HeroQuest Room

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests