Page 1 of 2
Talisman 3rd edition vs revised 4th
Posted:
December 2nd, 2013, 12:24 amby Nephew of Mentor
After having it pointed out to me in other posts, I noticed 3rd edition and its expansions have great HQ compatible minis. How do the minis in the core package compare to those in 4th edition? Since i now browse the net almost exclusively from a smart phone it can be hard to compare.
I have seen some great minis that would fit in as Sir Ragnar, Pierre Chancier, Killi, Millandriel, as well as Legacy of Sorasil heroes. I am sure all the ones I want are oop and worth their weight in gold now, but it would be nice to know the differences between the editions. Thanks.
Re: Talisman 3rd edition vs revised 4th
Posted:
December 2nd, 2013, 1:04 amby chaoticprime
The miniatures for both games are miniatures. Also, Talisman 3rd is easy to obtain.
Re: Talisman 3rd edition vs revised 4th
Posted:
December 2nd, 2013, 6:13 pmby Nephew of Mentor
Is the artistic style similar?
Re: Talisman 3rd edition vs revised 4th
Posted:
December 2nd, 2013, 6:29 pmby Goblin-King
Not THAT similar. Talisman are noticeable bigger and with somewhat bigger heads.
Design-wise and overall look is close enough for them to not look out of place. Especially if you compare to the more detailed minis of the later expansions.
It's not perfect, but it'll do. The minis are pretty cool in their own right.
Easy to obtain? Yes! Cheaply? Well, from £6 and up to around £15
Edit:
Maybe I misunderstood? I just compared 3rd to HQ.
Re: Talisman 3rd edition vs revised 4th
Posted:
December 2nd, 2013, 7:35 pmby chaoticprime
Talisman 3rd minis fit nicely with HQ. Talisman 4th minis do not at all.
Re: Talisman 3rd edition vs revised 4th
Posted:
December 2nd, 2013, 8:04 pmby Nephew of Mentor
chaoticprime wrote:Talisman 3rd minis fit nicely with HQ. Talisman 4th minis do not at all.
Sadly, this is what I suspected. A shame.
Re: Talisman 3rd edition vs revised 4th
Posted:
December 3rd, 2013, 11:58 amby knightkrawler
It's a Fantasy Flight Sickness. They would make great minis, but somehow they think they sell more games than they would if they used 28mm.
Re: Talisman 3rd edition vs revised 4th
Posted:
December 3rd, 2013, 12:30 pmby Goblin-King
Fantasy Flight wrote:Let's make sure our miniatures aren't compatible with other popular games.
People should buy our game because they want to actually play it, not to just scavenge the figures.
Re: Talisman 3rd edition vs revised 4th
Posted:
December 3rd, 2013, 12:43 pmby knightkrawler
Touché.
Re: Talisman 3rd edition vs revised 4th
Posted:
December 4th, 2013, 8:17 amby Jackyboy
I have Talisman 3rd Edition with all the expansions. The figures are great and I would say that they will fit perfectly with HeroQuest. I haven't measured them exactly but they look pretty much the same size
There are a few characters which I plan on using as playable and non playable characters in homebrew quests and there is definitely a rich supply of Wizard archetypes to get creative with.
Additionally I think Talisman 3rd Edition is an amazing game and would recommend you purchasing it to play the actual game as well as share its miniatures with HeroQuest
