Gold Bearer wrote:Why only daggers?
Gold Bearer wrote:Why does being wounded with a poisoned dagger do no damage,
I see only two other ways to deliver Poison:
Smeared on sword or a
Blow gun.I have a problem with both of these.
SMEARED ON SWORD =A) The Poison stays on your sword throughout the fight till you do a BP of damage.
B) The poison stays on your sword for your first attack only.
Problems:A) This is a waste of Poison since most monsters have only 1BP or 2BPs & will likely be killed soon.
B) Waste of poison if the monster defends.
A) & B) Possible waste of poison if the only creature you are
able to attack is a Goblin who you kill in one swing along with your Poison.
A) & B) Your sword needs to be smeared on your turn before entering a room, otherwise in combat you'd need to spend a turn re-smearing. I can't imagine a hero with 4 attack & 5 defend bothering with this.
BLOW GUN =A) You have unlimited Darts at 1CD per shot.
B) Each Dart cost X amount of $ at 1CD per shot.
Problems:
A) Unlimited Darts would be absurd unless the Poison for them cost a huge amount of $ per quest for it to do BP damage.
B) Buying individual Darts seems thematically funny to me.
A) & B) A Dart does no BodyPoint damage (popularly) & can still be defended against?!
A) & B) Both require two free hands. I just don't see anyone but the Wizard wanting this weapon.
Conclusion:Most heros have either a Crossbow or Bow and aren't interested in a 1CD missile weapon that can be defended against, especially if they spent $ on Poison for it whether its a Dagger or any other 1CD weapon. That's why it has to be undefendable & in so being undefendable is the reason it should not be allowed to do BP damage.
Poisons are meant to be similar to a spell, but for non magic users. Also unlike other poison delivery systems, its one handed and you don't have to "smear" before use since its own sheath can be filled with the poison at the beginning of the quest. It also simply makes Daggers more useful in the game.
Anyway, I can't find a better delivery system for poison on the site & will have to keep digging.
Would love to hear yours or others though.