by Nephew of Mentor » December 11th, 2012, 10:45 pm
Since you asked for stories of players being killed. I had a first time group that started out completely overconfident in the first level. I guess they killed a goblin without any trouble and assumed it would be that way for the whole quest. They all went off on their own and one by one were destroyed. The next time they played they had learned their lessons, unfortunately, the dice decided to teach them a lesson, and in record time the whole group was slaughtered, even after using all of their spells and potions.
One game that I expected to end poorly went quite the other way. In quest 6 the group was struggling to escape the dungeon. They were all very low on health, and had expended all healing spells and potions. Unfortunately for them, the big baddie and all his retinue were standing between them and the exit. Their only hope was with the wizard, who still had all his most deadly spells. His turn came, and sure enough, he cast pass through rock, rolled 12, and walked through the two rooms straight to the exit, leaving his party behind. Miraculously, the party won through, but in revenge they left behind the staff and wizard's cloak carried by the orc warlord's heir.
Sure it's pretty scary when the witch lord returns but what you should really be afraid of is "Resurrection of the Witch Lord". Resurrected baddies always come back more threatening than ever, usually kind of demonic with wings and horns and hell fire to announce their arrival. Think Gannondorf or Mother Brain from Super Metroid.